Deck of Scarlet Review – Is One Palette Really Worth It?


Overall Rating

Get The Deal

Right now, Deck of Scarlet is offering 30% of the initial purchase price. Opting into this deal is simple - it redeems itself at checkout.

Rose Gold 7 in 1 Curling Wand by FoxyBae

With thousands of brands, styles and looks to choose from, even the most experienced makeup artists can have trouble figuring out where to start time to time. 

Deck of Scarlet is a beauty subscription program that saves you so much time in trying to create a put together look.

They resolve this issue by providing subscribers with their own palette every two months. Inside this palette, you will find an assortment of products that work cohesively to create an entire makeup look.

It is one of the more unique types of beauty boxes, but no less popular. Over the years it has been recognized by names like Refinery29, Hello Giggles, Yahoo Beauty, Bustle, Glamour, WWD, Allure, and People.

How Does It Work?

Every two months Deck of Scarlet collaborates with a YouTuber to create a new makeup palette, plus one additional full-sized item. Each palette is curated to be trendy, season appropriate, and to help you achieve multiple makeup looks. 

If you struggle with creating new makeup looks, as a subscriber you will be granted with access to how-to tutorials using all of the products you receive!

When you begin your subscription, you’ll have the option to choose your first palette at check out. An email to preview each new palette one week before it launches will be sent to your inbox after you receive your first order.

See a palette that you don't like? That's not a problem. Deck of Scarlet allows you 5 days before billing to skip the next palette. To opt in to a palette, you don't have to do anything! You'll be billed according to schedule.


  • Cruelty-free
  • check
  • check
    Excellent quality
  • check
    Made in the USA
  • Free shipping


  • Questionable customer service
  • Only one brand - not very diverse

Plans & Pricing

As a subscriber you can expect to receive an order every other month because Deck of Scarlett comes out with a new palette every two months. Each palette is priced at $29.95 and is over $120 in value. Mind that you do not pay each month, but each time an order is shipped to you. 

See a palette that may not fit your style? If that's the case, no worries! You may skip a palette at any time by contacting administrators at

If this is your first order, please allow up to 20 business days for your order to ship and another 7-10 business days for delivery.

All recurring orders leave their warehouse mid-month, and usually arrive within 7-10 business days after shipment. Deck of Scarlet ships in batches, and delivery time can vary each month. 

At the moment they only offer shipping to US, Canada, and U.K. residents, but down the line they will be expanding to more countries so be sure to stay tuned!

Customer Reviews

Customer reviews are an important piece of what makes up an essence of a product or service. You can usually catch wind of what the turn out will be considering the feedback that is given.

In Deck of Scarlet reviews, responses were half and half.  

Initially one would think that one palette seems a little skimpy, but those that were happy loved the vast amount of looks that a single palette can make. The makeup itself is very pigmented, too, which means the quality is good. The less pigment, the lesser quality of makeup. Customers loved that they didn't have to put too much on their brush to achieve their look.

Those who weren't satisfied with the company had an issue with the manner of communication. Customer service is just as important as any other factor while considering a potential product or service, because if you have an issue, that's where you go to. With bad customer service, it's more difficult to get questions answered or problems resolved. 

The bad communication with Deck of Scarlet consisted of sporadic emails or failure to get back. This isn't the best thing to hear, but overall the quality of the products you are receiving make it worth it in my opinion. It all just depend on what you are willing to deal with. 

Have your own experience with Deck of Scarlet? We want to hear what you think. Leave a review in the comments below.

The Competition

Nowadays there are thousands of beauty boxes to choose from. While this is a definite luxury, how do you know if you're choosing the right. Let's take a look at how Deck of Scarlet compares to BoxyCharm, one of it's biggest competitors. 

Deck of Scarlet immediately stands out because they create their own products unlike BoxyCharm who simply curates products from other companies. It's also more limited in the types of products you receive since you are getting generally the same palette every other month, just in different shades. BoxyCharm usually sends out a variety of popular mainstream products, and it's a little more unpredictable.

Subscription-wise, BoxyCharm is a monthly service, while Deck of Scarlet is bimonthly. Deck of Scarlet is more expensive, but the value for cost is better making it more worth your while. 

Customer service is questionable with both companies, so neither stand out at being better in that particular area. 

Overall, both companies have their pros and cons thus it all depends on what you're looking for in a beauty subscription box. Deck of Scarlet wins in quality and uniqueness, while BoxyCharm is great in giving subscribers more regular shipments. Ultimately it just depends on which factors are most important you.

If you have any additional questions about BoxyCharm, check out our full BoxyCharm review for more details.

Are Deck of Scarlet Products Safe?

With Deck of Scarlet there have been up to 9 different palettes so far, and they come out with more every other month!

Each palette comes with a few eyeshadows, highlighter, blush, gloss and a lip color. The product inside the palette is full-sized and highly pigmented. 

They are 100% safe to use. In fact, all products featured in the palette are cruelty-free, paraben-free and made in the United States.

Is It Right For Me?

If you're someone who's looking for something different from the standard beauty subscription box, then Deck of Scarlet is right up your alley. It also is great for anyone who struggles creating a cohesive makeup look.

Deck of Scarlet is product specific, therefore if you want more of a variety in your subscription box then Deck of Scarlet is not the one for you.

Deals and Coupons 

One of the great things about Deck of Scarlet is their deals! They are offering new deals all the time. Literally all the time. Right now they are offering 30% off of the initial subscription price. Go to checkout to redeem this fantastic deal!


Quality of Products
Value For Cost
Customer Service
Previous articlePetit Vour Review – Is It Really The Better Alternative?
Next articleBeauty Heroes Review – Is It Actually What It’s Hyped Up To Be?
Sydney enjoys using her writing skills to help people make smarter purchasing decisions and save money. She enjoys researching and writing reviews and other articles here on DealMeisters and other several other sites.


  1. Quality of Products


    Value For Cost


    Customer Service


    I struggle with putting makeup looks together so this palette helps me out big time lol

    • We’re glad to hear that Deck of Scarlet has been working out well for you, Shauna. Thanks for sharing with us!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here