Omaha Steaks Review – They Deliver Quality Meats But Is It Worth It?

13
6366

omaha steaks burger

Overall Rating

Read User Reviews

Get The Deal

Join today and get free shipping on your first order.

Omaha Steaks International is a family-owned company that excels in providing premium steaks, other meats, and sides to their customers. The company was founded in 1917 by the Simon family, who still run the company today. Self-branded as a “Table Supply Meat Company,” Omaha Steaks is the first company to offer a meal-to-table subscription service, arguably paving the way for companies like Blue Apron, HelloFresh, and Plated.

Omaha Steaks annually cuts, trims, and ships 14 million pounds of beef. They are responsible for hand-crafting every single pound in-house. The company is based in Omaha, Nebraska but also features over 70 retail stores nationwide.

How Does It Work?

Omaha Steaks offer a-la-carte options, something not seen by other meal-subscription services. Customers can buy as much or as little meat as they’d like at a time. There are a vast amount of options available when ordering from Omaha Steaks to the point where it seems overwhelming at times.

Customers can shop by:

  • Meats
  • Seafood
  • Meals & Occasions
  • Starters & Sides
  • Desserts
  • Wine
  • Gifts
  • BBQ
  • Business Gifts

There is no shortage of items available, and the fact that they can be ordered at any time provides significantly more flexibility and convenience than other meal delivery services.  Some meal delivery services don’t even grant the option to choose which meals you’d like. With a selection like this, you won't have to take nearly as many trips to the grocery store!

The company does offer an AutoShip & Save option, eliminating the hassle of having to select an order every time you run low. For the sake of the review, we’re going to focus on this portion of the Omaha Steaks website, since it most directly compares to other at-home meal subscription services you may be familiar with.

When selecting an AutoShip & Save option, customers can choose from

  • Shipping Included Combos
  • Bulk Proteins
  • Complete Meals
  • Custom Combos
  • Custom Meals

Customers can choose to have the order delivered

  • Every Week
  • Every Two Weeks
  • Every Three Weeks
  • Every Four Weeks
  • Every Five Weeks
  • Every Six Weeks
  • Every Month
  • Every Two Months
  • Every Three Months
  • Every Four Months
  • Every Five Months
  • Every Six Months
  • Annually

Omaha Steaks states that the customers who use their AutoShip & Save service are guaranteed the best possible price on their regular shipments. The price of a customer’s original purchase is locked in for 12 months, even if the price of the package increases. Additionally, any subsequent AutoShip order is subject to a 5% discount.

The company has also said that if they offer a lower AutoShip price on your package within 30 days of your ordering, they’ll offer a 5% discount on the marked down price. So, if you order a package for $110 but then Omaha Steaks offers the package for $100, you’ll receive the package for $95.

Another added bonus of ordering through Omaha Steaks is that all United States Military service members are entitled to a 10% discount on any subsequent AutoShip order.

The AutoShip feature also allows customers to enough food to host a party. Say, for example, you host a summer party annually each year. Omaha Steaks allows customers to order food for the party and then select an annual AutoShip option so that it automatically arrives in time for next year’s party.

This again is considerably different than other meal delivery services, which typically only offer weekly or monthly deliveries. And, the portion sizes of a meal on other meal delivery services are often capped at six people, so it’s not possible to order enough food for a larger gathering.

Omaha Steaks allows customers to pause their AutoShip subscription service at any time and offers a 100% guarantee on every AutoShip purchase. The company also offers a rewards program. Each purchase allows customers to earn points, which can then be used for free food products and discounts.

Pros

  • Many meal options to choose from
  • Company-guaranteed price and food quality 
  • Very flexible shipping options 

Cons

  • Very pricey 
  • Limited vegan options

Shipping and Packaging

Omaha Steaks delivers your package in what they call “Mini Deep Freeze” packaging, which is an insulated cooler made of polystyrene, kept cool with lots of dry ice. So your order is kept fresh and safe all the way to your doorstep. And you can even re-use the delivery cooler for other things, just like you would use a cooler you buy from the store!

Plans & Pricing

Omaha Steaks’ AutoShip & Save is considerably more expensive than other meal-delivery options. Below is the breakdown of the various AutoShip options available.

Shipping Included Combos

As indicated, shipping is included in these meals. The Omaha Steaks Classics Collection comes with 20 total items and is available for $79.99. The Family Dinner Faves Combo comes with 15 total items and is available for $89.99. The Best of Omaha Steaks package, which comes with 15 items, can be purchased for $69.99.

Lastly, the Premium Skillet Favorites Collection, which comes with five total items and a free meal, is available for $99.00.

Bulk Proteins

If you’re not concerned about the sides but are interested in quality meats to last for weeks or months at a time, these deals may be right for you. The Gourmet-Protein Bulk Up is $219.00 and comes with 32 total items. The Filet Mignon package is $210.00 and comes with 16 cuts of meat.

32 Omaha Steaks Burgers and 32 Gourmet Jumbo Franks can be had for $99.00 total. 40 Chicken Breasts and 40 Pork Chops can be purchased for $160.00 total.

Complete Meals

The Steak and Cake Combo is a meal for four, available for $69.99. The Ribeye Dinner is a meal for four, available for $99.00. The Filet Mignon Feast is a meal for four available for $69.99 per person, and the Ultimate Burger Cookout is a meal for eight available for $39.99 total.

Custom Combos

This deal allows customers to pick a number of items for a certain price. Items vary, and they do not necessarily have to be packaged as an entire meal. The Value Custom Combo is $59.99, and customers select four of 34 selections. The Select Custom Combo is $79.99, and customers select six out of 44 selections.

The Family Custom Combo is $104.99, and customers selection six out of 50 selections. The Deluxe Custom Combo is $114.99 and allows customers to select six of 46 selections. Options for these combos range from “Two Filet Mignons + Two Top Sirloins” to “Four Chicken Fried Steaks.”

Custom Meals

A gourmet dinner for four is $64.99 total or $16.25 per person. That’s just for one meal! If you order two complete dinners, you’ll save a bit, as the price drops to $114.99 total. A complete family dinner for six is $79.99, and a steak dinner for four is $99.99. When selecting meals, customers select one appetizer, one meat, one side dish, and one dessert.

If you're not buying for yourself, Omaha Steaks also gives you the option to hand-pick gift baskets.

Customer Reviews

Omaha Steaks Reviews often vary. There are not many Omaha Steak reviews about the specific AutoShip feature. Customer reviews on ChowHound were generally not satisfied with the meats, with many reviewers considering them overpriced.

Want to share your own experience with Omaha Steaks? Tell the community what you think! Leave your Omaha Steaks review in the comments below.

Overall Customer Rating

After reviewing various customer reviews online, the overall customer rating of Omaha Steaks is 6/10.

Want to share your own experience with Omaha Steaks? Tell the community what you think! Leave your review in the comments below.

Recipes Available At Omaha Steaks

Omaha Steaks provides a Recipe Center, allowing customers to find recipes that their products can be used for. Many of their crock-pot meals are very popular, considering it is so simple!

Customers will have to provide many of the ingredients necessary to make these recipes since Omaha Steaks only ships meats and primary sides, as opposed to individual ingredients.

Our three favorites were:

Steak Burger with Grilled Cherry Heirloom Tomatoes. Ingredients required include:

  • Omaha Steaks Jumbo Steak Burgers
  • 8 slices artisan sourdough bread
  • ¼ cup stone ground mustard
  • ½ cup arugula
  • ¾ cup cherry heirloom tomatoes
  • 2 tbsp fennel greens (rough chop)
  • 2 tbsp olive oil
  • ½ tsp fresh garlic minced
  • 1 tsp balsamic vinegar
  • Sea salt to taste
  • Fresh ground black pepper to taste

Steak Burger with Grilled Cherry Heirloom Tomato

Easy Beef Steak Diane. Ingredients required include:

  • 2 Omaha Steaks Boneless Strip Steaks
  • 1 teaspoon grated lemon peel
  • ¼ teaspoon pepper
  • 1 tablespoon vegetable oil
  • ½ pound small mushrooms, sliced
  • 2 tablespoons finely chopped shallots or green onion
  • 1 tablespoon brandy, optional
  • ¼ cup half – and – half
  • 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
  • 2 teaspoons Dijon-style mustard
  • 2 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce

Easy Beef Steak Diane

Ancho Bhil Rubbed Grilled Porterhouse Steaks. Ingredients required include:

  • 4 each Porterhouse steaks
  • 2 tbsp olive oil
  • 4 tbsp ancho chile rub
  • 12 each grilled tri-color salad peppers
  • 1 tbsp smoked paprika
  • 2 tsp sea salt
  • 2 tbsp ancho chile powder
  • 1 tsp brown sugar

Ancho Chile Rubbed Grilled Porterhouse Steaks

Omaha Steaks vs The Competition

Omaha Steaks is one-of-a-kind when it comes to meal-subscription services. They are different from subscription services like Blue Apron because of what food can be ordered and how often it can be ordered. There is much more flexibility in Omaha’s ordering system, and the ability to add a-la-carte options is unmatched.

However, Omaha Steaks does not really send meals that are ready-to-prepare. In some ways they do. A steak can be taken out of the packaging and placed on the grill. But if you wish to create a recipe offered on the website like the ones mentioned above, you’ll need to provide many of the ingredients.

Omaha Steaks is also much more expensive than other meal delivery services. Some may argue that this is because of the quality of meats. Whether it is worth it or not is truly up to you.

Is It Right For Me?

Simply put, Omaha Steaks is best for meat lovers with deep wallets. If you have money to spend on quality meats, then it’s worth considering Omaha Steaks.

Or if you have a family member or friend who loves steaks, you can give them a gift card to one of the highest quality viagra companies around (think Father's Day or maybe Valentine's Day)!

Deals and Coupons

Omaha Steaks is constantly offering deals for their online orders, which can be found here. Additionally, the company offers a deal that allows customers to upgrade to Private Reserve cuts of meat for free. Information on that deal can be found here.

Review Summary/Overview

Omaha Steaks has a long-recognized history in the food industry. The Omaha Steaks AutoShip & Save feature is noticeably different than other meal-subscription services because of the variety and flexibility it offers. But, this steak company is also considerably more expensive than other meal-subscription services.

13 COMMENTS

  1. Taste

    10.00

    Ease of Preparation

    9.80

    Variety of Meal Options

    10.00

    Value for Cost

    9.00

    Customer Service

    10.00

    Tried Omaha Steaks after a friend of mine kept telling me how great they were. I love shopping from home and Omaha Steaks offers so many different meats. Your desserts are delicious too. Can’t wait to try your slow cooker meals.

    • Thanks for your awesome feedback, Amy! Really happy to hear you enjoy Omaha Steaks. Shopping from home is a big convenience.

  2. Taste

    9.00

    Ease of Preparation

    10.00

    Variety of Meal Options

    10.00

    Value for Cost

    8.00

    Customer Service

    10.00

    I thought some of the steaks were a bit smaller than what you could buy in the grocery store although they did taste very good. I did enjoy the pork chops and the burgers as well.

    • Thanks for your feedback, Jean! Sorry to hear the steak sizes were a bit small. I’m glad you did enjoy the pork chops and burgers and hope you’ll continue to like some of the other foods.

  3. Taste

    9.50

    Ease of Preparation

    10.00

    Variety of Meal Options

    10.00

    Value for Cost

    7.00

    Customer Service

    10.00

    Omaha Steaks is just a bit too expensive for me. I received it as a gift and I did enjoy the food. I have a large family so it just seems to be too much for me to pay.

    • Thanks for sharing with us, Michelle! I’m sorry to hear about the prices being too expensive for you. I’m glad you did enjoy the food though.

  4. Taste

    10.00

    Ease of Preparation

    10.00

    Variety of Meal Options

    10.00

    Value for Cost

    9.50

    Customer Service

    10.00

    I received Omaha Steaks as a gift from a friend of mine and I think their foods are great. I’m definitely gonna order some more food and I can’t wait to try the desserts.

    • Thanks, Missy for your feedback! I’m happy to hear You’re enjoying the food at Omaha Steaks. Hope those desserts are fantastic!

  5. Taste

    10.00

    Ease of Preparation

    10.00

    Variety of Meal Options

    10.00

    Value for Cost

    8.50

    Customer Service

    10.00

    The only complaint I have about Omaha Steaks is that the portions could be a bit bigger. The food tastes great and I have received all my shipments on time.

    • Thanks for sharing your feedback with us, Ben! Sorry to hear the portions were too small. I’m glad you did enjoy the food though.

  6. Taste

    5.60

    Ease of Preparation

    7.30

    Variety of Meal Options

    1.00

    Value for Cost

    0.70

    Customer Service

    0.00

    My two small steaks were tender and juicy and we totally enjoyed them. Our problem is that for the 69.99 paid really the only items of value were the steaks, everything else in the box was filler. Chicken breast, Hot Dogs, Hamburgers… Really? What a waste of money. If my budget was $69.99 for basically 2 steaks at my local meat market can you imagine the cuts I’d get? OMG! 2 $35 dollar steaks? Best you’ll probably ever eat. Plus, Larry the butcher moves 2 more porterhouses. Bottom line: Skip Omaha ‘Steaks’, go to the store!

  7. My order sat in their office for 4 days before shipping. It arrived on the lengthy schedule they gave me, but most of that time was spent sitting in their office and warehouse.

    Any vendor that can’t ship within two days isn’t managing their process efficiently for the customer.

    About their customer service: it took 45 minutes on hold to reach a representative on day 3 of waiting for my order to ship. They told me the order had already shipped when in fact their own website showed the order status as still processing.

    Also they don’t tell you that they’re going to bill you a significant shipping and handling charge. You don’t see that shipping charge until the end of the order, and by then you’ve spent so much time going through all the ordering process and rejecting all the ads to buy more useless products that it’s wasted even more of your time.

    No good customer service! Don’t order from them, they’re only a marketing company.

  8. Taste

    10.00

    Ease of Preparation

    10.00

    Variety of Meal Options

    10.00

    Value for Cost

    10.00

    Customer Service

    10.00

    My brother was gracious enough to send us a gift containing Omaha Steaks for Christmas. What a joy. They cooked perfect and tasted even better.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here