Buying a mattress online is become more popular but finding the right one can be a difficult task. High-quality choices like Tuft and Needle and Casper offer great options for those looking for mattresses made from memory foam but finding which one is right for you is important.
In this review, we'll take an in-depth look at the pros and cons of each mattress and what you need to know before you decide what to buy.
Twin 50 lbs.,
Twin XL 52 lbs.,
Full 63 lbs.,
Queen 72 lbs.,
King 94 lbs.,
Cal King 94 lbs.
Soft but supportive
$325 - $700
Up to 10 years
The Tuft and Needle mattress is made from seriously high-quality foam and is comprised of two layers. These two layers are designed for ultimate breathability and covered with a white cover that is thin enough to breathe and not obstruct the release of heat from sleepers during the night.
The foam used by Tuft and Needle is a type of memory foam that is super responsive while still being comfortable for a number of sleeping positions and people of different weights. The cover of this mattress is thin which can make it more prone to damage from rough handling.
The firmness of Tuft and Needle is on the low side of medium firm and is generally considered to feel soft but very supportive. It has excellent motion isolation which allows even light sleepers to be undisturbed by the movements of their partner.
The Tuft and Needle mattress offers a great value for the price, and online reviews are very good as owners everywhere are very pleased with their purchase. This mattress is also a little lighter than the competition which means that one person could potentially maneuver it themselves.
Twin 44 lbs.,
Twin XL 46 lbs.,
Full 60 lbs.,
Queen 71 lbs.,
King 91 lbs.,
Cal King 90 lbs.
$595 - $1195
7 - 10 years
The Casper mattress is constructed of four layers of different kinds of foam, each designed to help deliver an overall great feel when resting, and comfort while you sleep. Casper offers great breathability and comes with a white cover which is thin enough to help facilitate airflow and keep sleepers extra cool.
The thinner cover may increase breathability but it can also more easily be damaged, so owners are encouraged to exercise care when moving and handling their mattress. The four layers of foam are different thicknesses with the base layer being the thickest. The layers put above the base are thinner and made from different materials to optimize performance.
Having multiple layers of responsive foam helps make this mattress the best mattress for multiple sleeping positions and it’s a crowd pleaser if you sleep with a partner as well. Casper has excellent motion isolation qualities due to the hybrid mix of foam it has, and it is made from excellent quality materials.
Firmness and Support
There's not a clear winner when it comes to firmness and support with the Casper and Tuft and Needle mattresses. Both offer a similar experience and similar firmness that allows many owners to have a very comfortable experience.
The most frequent descriptors used for both mattresses are “soft” and “supportive” with emphasis on overall comfort. The breathability also contributes to the feeling of support because it helps to limit how hot a sleeper will feel and therefore allows them to better enjoy feeling more supported.
Both mattresses are on the lower end of medium firm which has become the most popular level of firmness in recent years. While previous mattresses were solidly in the medium firm category, recent changes to materials have allowed these mattresses to use softer feeling layers without sacrificing the feeling of support.
Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses are both very good at motion isolation and the customer reviews are more than adequate proof. While the Casper is slightly less great at motion isolation than the Tuft and Needle mattress, the difference is small and not noticeable.
For those that share a bed with another person or pets, advanced motion isolation can help you get a better night’s sleep. Tuft and Needle and Casper have taken this to heart with their material selection to ensure that owners can sleep undisturbed no matter how much their partner moves during the night.
Construction and Materials
Like many brands, the construction of both the Casper and Tuft and Needle are different in many ways. Casper boasts a blend of 4 layers of foam that are responsive and comfortable while Tuft and Needle have two that provide a great base and a responsive top layer.
Both brands construct their mattresses out of very high-quality foam and their design keeps breathability and comfort in mind. For those that live in hotter climates, a highly breathable foam is a must in order to avoid overheating, and durability is an ongoing concern for buyers.
The materials used in these two brands have exceptional life spans which demonstrate how carefully Tuft and Needle and Casper have worked to properly source their materials. Both brands have 10-year warranties which also backs up their claims that their mattresses are of excellent quality and built to last.
Off-Gassing and Smell
Tuft and Needle and Casper have been very careful with their material selection not just for durability and comfort, but for off-gassing and smell as well. Their materials are carefully sourced from certified manufacturers and checked regularly to ensure quality.
Many foam mattresses will have some kind of smell that will need to air out and this can be bothersome to those with sensitivities. High-quality mattresses like Casper and Tuft and Needle are manufactured without harmful chemicals or compounds that are likely to release a chemical type smell.
Both mattresses are also packaged carefully in such a way that they cannot pick up smells during travel or set up. Once you unpackage and unroll them they should smell fresh and be ready for use almost immediately.
The difference in price between the Casper and Tuft and Needle can likely be attributed to the number of layers, and innovative materials used. Quality, durability, and comfort are very similar with both mattresses.
- Tuft and Needle average price of Queen mattress: $575
- Casper average price of Queen mattress: $995
- Industry average price of Queen mattress: $860
Who Should Buy Tuft & Needle?
Tuft and Needle is good for those who are looking for a high-quality foam mattress with luxury features but at a budget price. Customer service and their return policy are excellent, and customers have 100 days to decide. Check out our review to get more info.
Who Should Buy Casper?
The Casper is a great choice for those who want a high-quality mattress with high-end features, at a much more reasonable price. It has more layers than Tuft and Needle and a slightly different feel, but the similarities otherwise are abundant. If you'd like to learn more, check out our review.
Check out our Top 10 Best Mattresses list.